How to Select Ideal Colours and Fonts for Custom Pie Box Packaging?

  • Rating: 4.7/5
  • Posted On: April 15, 2025
  • Written by: Emenac Packaging Canada
  • Category: Blog
How-to-Select-Ideal-Colours-and-Fonts-for-Custom-Pie-Box-Packaging-EP-Canada

What customers experience first at your bakery isn’t the smell of a fresh-baked pie; it’s your packaging. For bakery owners, packaging designers, and marketing professionals, designing the ultimate custom pie box packaging is as much about aesthetics as it is about utility.

Proper colours and fonts on the packaging speak about the personality, style and even quality of your products before someone takes a bite.

But how does one select not just beautiful colours and fonts, but ones that both speak to your audience and do justice to your brand?

From exploring the psychology behind colour choices to the art of utilising typography that leaves a mark, this guide will navigate you through all the information you need for choosing the ideal colours and fonts when creating your custom pie boxes.

How Important Custom Pie Box Packaging Images Are?

Pie boxes are not just containers; they are an extension of your brand and one of the most impactful marketing tools ever. The product packaging design influences the purchasing decision of 72% of consumers, according to studies.

Attractive and consistent packaging establishes trust, conveys quality, and differentiates you from the competition.

So as you go to design your pie box, you’ll want to hone in on the things most likely to catch a customer’s eye and appeal to their emotions.

Talk about memorable experiences that get your customers coming back for more, this is where colours and fonts come into play by making your Collage not only attractive to customers but also memorable.

Understanding Colour Psychology in Packaging

Colours are not mere visual elements as they elicit feelings, form associations, and affect behavior. Having a clear understanding of colour psychology can help you decide how to approach your custom pie box packaging designs.

Common Colour Associations:

When we think about specific colours, red is often associated with: Energy, Passion, Stimulation of appetite. Ideal for bold, irresistible flavors.

Yellow: Glee and exuberance. Does well alongside upbeat, family-centric brands.

Green: Nature, health, and freshness. Great for homemade pies or organic pies.

Brown: Warmth, tradition, dependability. Perfect for traditional or rustic pie flavors.

Blue: Trust, stability, and quality. A good option for high-end desserts or premium ones.

Use Colour Psychology: Tips on Applying Colour Psychology

1. Get to Know Your Brand Personality

Your bakery might have a branding that is bigger than you are, such as gluten-free, organic pies, so soothing greens and earthy tones can validate that idea, for instance. If your brand is vintage and homemade, browns and soft pastels work better.

2. Cater to Your Target Audience

Are you catering to families, foodies or corporate clients?’ Different colours may convey different messages to different audiences. Cheery, playful colours may be a hit with families, but neat, minimal tones may be more pleasing to corporate customers.

3. Accent with Contrast

Use contrasting colours for baker information such as your bakery name, flavors or call to action words like “Try Me!” Contrast also helps your packaging design to be unique on the shelves.

4. Choosing Fonts for Readability and Enjoyment

If colours create the mood, fonts provide the voice to a packaging design. The font you choose to use is important to your branding being readable, professional and inviting.

5. Choosing the Perfect Font

Serif Fonts (e.g., Times New Roman): Impart a sense of belonging, elegance, or tradition. They are effective for upscale or vintage-style bakeries.

Sans Serif Fonts (e.g., Helvetica, Montserrat): Sleek, contemporary, and adaptable, these fonts are incredibly readable at any size.

Script Fonts (e.g., Pacifico, Great Vibes): Script fonts convey a sense of elegance,  creativity, or personalisation. But they should be used sparingly for clarity.

Display Fonts (e.g., Lobster, Cooper Black): Playful and attention-grabbing for prominent phrases or taglines, but do not use these in body text.

Typography Tips

1. Keep it Clear and Readable

Revamped product and brand information that customers can read at a glance, even from a distance. Steer clear of highly ornate or decorative fonts for main details.

2. Use an Appropriate Font Size

Use larger font sizes for your bakery name or tagline,  while descriptions of flavors and other information can be somewhat smaller. A consistent hierarchy will help improve the readability and visual flow.

3. Pair Fonts Strategically

Limit the number of fonts on your packaging to no more than two to three. Use Complimentary but Different Fonts: Pairing fonts that complement and pair together, like a bold sans serif for headings with a clean serif or sans serif for small text.

4. Mixing Colours and Typography to Express Your Brand

After you’ve chosen your colours and fonts on their own, the next step is to meld them together into a unified design that reflects your bakery’s identity.

Design Key Elements

Logo

Include your logo front and center and make sure the colours and fonts it has match the rest of your pie box design. A strong, consistent logo creates brand recognition.

Flavor Indicators

Add obvious hues or accents on your wrapping to delineate flavors. For instance, mint green for a key lime pie, warm orange colour for pumpkin pie.

Background and Contrast

Balance colourful pops with neutral-toned backgrounds to avoid a busy design. Combine bold fonts and muted colour or ornate fonts with minimal colour palettes.

Even the best designs need testing to determine how well they perform in the wild. Here’s how to playtest your pie box design well:

Testing Strategies

Print Samples

When you make use of the printing functions, always print out a few of your designs, as using a screen gives you an idea of how your colours, fonts and designs will look.

Customer Feedback

Give samples to a small test group of customers or ask a few loyal patrons their thoughts on your packaging. That perspective can illuminate strengths or problems you hadn’t thought of.

Shelf Comparison

Put your pie box alongside competitors’ packaging on a mock shelf. Does it stand out? Is it easy to read? Real-world context testing is gold.

Make Packaging Choices That Can Enhance Your Brand

Packaging is not just a functional need; this is a space for talking to the customers about your story and values. Whether you’re picking colours based on customer psychographics or matching fonts for flow and readability, all design decisions are significant.

Through colour psychology, typography and testing your designs, you can create custom pie box packaging that’s as good as your recipes.

Looking for a hand improving your packaging? Contact our team of experts to get your designs right. We’ll help your pies look as good as they taste!